BAN on '1 Member' GUILD FIGHTING GVG

  • Thread starter DeletedUser8152
  • Start date

Would you like to see this implemented?

  • Yes

    Votes: 35 53.0%
  • No

    Votes: 31 47.0%

  • Total voters
    66
  • Poll closed .

DeletedUser8152

BAN ON '1 MEMBER' GUILD FIGHTING

Proposal:

Ban and prohibit one (1) member Guilds from fighting GVG on the Guild Continent Map.


Current System:

One player ('1 member') Guilds can be created and dissolved and re-created limitless times daily to fight (to disrupt and unfairly harass) other guilds.

Abuse prevention:

prevent abusing GVG by eliminating single person 'ghosting' tactics.

Visual Aids:

none


Conclusion:

First, the very definition of 'Guild' is an association or organization of persons or members. It is a plural entity for the benefit of MORE THAN ONE PERSON. Thus, the very fact to a GUILD can remain in existence with only ONE MEMBER is both against its design or purpose and its meaning. Second, many of good players, members and founders have quit FOE do to growing tired and weary of continuous '1 member' attacks in GVG. Third, there is a significant unfairness to allowing single member guild fighting - which is their low cost of goods for fighting. Fourth, i can find no '1 member' guild holding four or more tiles on a regular basis, thus they do not fight for Guild purposes, but for PvP or bullying purposes. Fifth, this proposal does not stop a 1 member guild from existing, or even holding current tiles; it would only prevent them from fighting GUILD (an association of members) vs GUILD (another organized group of members).

Original thread: https://forum.us.forgeofempires.com/showthread.php?11527-BAN-on-1-Member-GUILD-FIGHTING-GVG

This poll will close on 12-13-2015

Please use this thread for voting only. If you wish to discuss the feature, please use the original thread (see link above).