Oh, joy. The dead horse is back. OP: you forgot to put another option - the unsolicited fp one.
@Podling seems to have summed up my position on the issue rather well. IMPO, sniping is any contribution of unsolicited FPs and
@Johnny B. Goode, you can snort all you want, but your opinion is just that, an opinion. The math doesn't lie.
My beef with snipers has everything to do with the math. Had the developers 'remathed' the gbs when they decided to allow them to be leveled after L10, there'd be no such thing as a 'snipe zone' and a lot of people would be happier and less frazzled and this conversation would probably have never started umpteen years ago.
Here's my math:
- Diamonds = premium currency that is either earned or purchased.
- GBs can be built w/premium currency provided the player has a minimum of one blueprint.
- There is no way to determine by looking at a GB whether it was built by use of this method but the assumtion can be made that it might have been.
Sum: If I construct a GB, with or without the use of premium currency, it's mine. No ifs, ands, or buts.
MINE. Therefore, I should have a direct say in whether or not someone is permitted to contribute, not some algorithym designed to favor Friends, Guildies, and Neighbors.
I CHOOSE.
- If said Friends, Guildies, and Neighbors need my prints, they can ask.
- If I say, "No," too bad, so sad, suck it up, Cupcake.
- I'm not here to make others' games more pleasurable, profitable, or pleasing. I'm here to make MY game that way.
Having said all of that, "I get it" and don't need umpteen people telling me the truth of the matter. How do I know the "math isn't mathing?" The launch of the 5 newest GBs. There ain't no sweet spot and that's all I needed to support the point I've been making all of these years. Thank you, Inno, for finally confirming this suspicion!
I don't like being told that the value of my spending dollar is in face, less than a dollar. That's what we're told when snipe zones exist. All of this malarkey we've all heard for years about being careless and prevent sniping by only presenting lockable positions is just that -- malarkey.
IMHO, stopping this nonsense would have been achieved by two things and they've already done one of them -- fixed the math. Now all that needs doing is affording the GB owner the right to 'refuse contributions' by player, not group, and the problem of sniping is ancient history. Those who do may cry, whine, and even rage quit but at least the GB owner will have a
choice and choice is all I, for one, have ever wanted. Bring on the drop box, Inno. Been waiting to hear my dollar is worth a dollar for years!!
Oh, and for those of you who might be curious, the answer is "Yes. I've blown up GBs with sniper's fps on them. Plenty of times. I'd rather start over than give them a single print. I've machinated 1-fp up leveling parties to knock them from a reward spot if they were foolish enough not to lock themselves into position. I've paid FP bounties to the participants to truly make it worth their time and trouble to assist me. But, when all else fails, I break out the wrecking ball." If I brought a smile to your face or a laugh to your throat for admitting that, you're welcome. Happiness is hard to find these days and I'm glad to bring a bit your way. But I can assure you, no smile was bigger and no laugh louder, than the ones I've had watching their stupid forge points go up in smoke. None.
It was pure bliss.
Why? Because that building was MINE.