Donations to Treasury Quests

[MariB64]

Why is it that the Arc goods to the treasury do not count on the quests asking to donate goods to the guild treasury? Sorry if this questions has already been asked. Looked but couldn't find one if so.

 

[Johnny B. Goode]

Well, the only real answer is because Inno decided that it should be that way. My guess is that the underlying reason behind that decision is that those goods are never really in your possession, so you're not really "donating" them. With other GBs that produce goods for you (and do count for quests requiring you to "get goods") the goods are actually put into your goods inventory just like if you had gotten them from a goods building or special/event building.

 

[MariB64]

Well, the only real answer is because Inno decided that it should be that way. My guess is that the underlying reason behind that decision is that those goods are never really in your possession, so you're not really "donating" them. With other GBs that produce goods for you (and do count for quests requiring you to "get goods") the goods are actually put into your goods inventory just like if you had gotten them from a goods building or special/event building.

then why do the goods from statue of honor count as a donation on those quests. I know the arc ones used to as well, but now they do not.

 

[Pericles the Lion]

then why do the goods from statue of honor count as a donation on those quests. I know the arc ones used to as well, but now they do not.

Probably because the SoH is a special building. Its contributions count towards challenges same as the Airship, Royal Bathhouse, and Stage of Ages.

 

[Johnny B. Goode]

then why do the goods from statue of honor count as a donation on those quests. I know the arc ones used to as well, but now they do not.

No, the Arc goods never counted for donation quests. If they ever did for you, then it was a temporary glitch. And I've been playing since before the Arc was even around, just FYI.

 

[Karen Isaacsdottir]

then why do the goods from statue of honor count as a donation on those quests. I know the arc ones used to as well, but now they do not.

If they used to and no longer do, that could be a code defect. Document it and post it.

 

[Johnny B. Goode]

If they used to and no longer do, that could be a code defect. Document it and post it.

They never have. He is either mistaken, or he had a temporary glitch where they did count for him until it was fixed.

 

[I am master of greatness]

really? mine has always done that as well

They never have. He is either mistaken, or he had a temporary glitch where they did count for him until it was fixed.

it may be somthing to do with the world or somthing

 

[DevaCat]

Gotta say, Arc goods collections have never counted for those quests (shorter time frame than Johnny, but still). Think about it: that gb is already op (and I’m glad it’s so) but letting people with high level Arcs one-click those quests would basically break the quests portion of the game.

 

[Johnny B. Goode]

really? mine has always done that as well

it may be somthing to do with the world or somthing

No, yours hasn't always done that. And it has nothing to do with which world, they are all identical in mechanics. You are simply mistaken.

 

[Kranyar the Mysterious]

No, yours hasn't always done that. And it has nothing to do with which world, they are all identical in mechanics. You are simply mistaken.

^^^^ so much this! ^^^^

 

[I am master of greatness]

I do not no than it must be some sort of a glitch

 

[UP ONLINE]

Donations is something you need to give up from your stock
not only that it grows your power giving up your goods