Fellowship Event 2023 Feedback

[Ebeondi Asi]

653, 680 ,617 for my three Worlds is the minimum forGold League

 

[Dursland]

US29 Dilmun has the whales pushing Gold League up to 754.

Really glad I'm at 850.

 

[xivarmy]

Interestingly, Jaims is also knocking on 750 for the gold cutoff. Only one other than Dilmun that high among the ones I can check. I think someone might've mentioned S being high earlier in the event as well - but i'm not on that one.

Dilmun​	754​
Jaims​	744​
Birka​	683​
East Nagach​	682​
Langendorn​	676​
Yorkton​	674​
Fel Dranghyr​	666​
Qunrir​	660​
Houndsmoor​	658​
Arvahall​	654​
Brisgard​	653​
Cirgard​	649​
Noarsil​	649​
Carthage​	648​
Odhrovar​	645​
Xyr​	644​
Parkog​	643​
Dunarsund​	626​
Rugnir​	617​
​	​
Median​	654​
Average​	664​

 

[Dursland]

Interestingly, Jaims is also knocking on 750 for the gold cutoff. Only one other than Dilmun that high among the ones I can check. I think someone might've mentioned S being high earlier in the event as well - but i'm not on that one.

Heard US26 was high too, Angkor.

 

[PJS299]

Houndsmoor just moved up to 675. EDIT: I've gotten to 350 tasks, Bronze cutoff is 321. I have 5 gemstones left.

This is like watching an election, or an intense football game.
And @xivarmy, that is an impressive graph. Now that I think about it, you always seem to have a graph...

 

[Dursland]

Gotta love the graphs!

I will be getting a 6th golden from league, so I'm 4 upgrades away from a 6th Sunhaven.

Let's see how long BG and Smithy take to fill that out.

Really excited about next event. I did well in anniversary, ready for a repeat. Even better this time now that I know to add up totals of free currency + currency I plan to buy and get it all at the beginning, then divvy up by number of days.

 

[Ironrooster]

In my main city, without spending any diamonds or buying the prize line, I was able to complete 510 tasks which put me 50 into Silver League. This was good enough for 2 Sunhavens.

All my other cities I completed the quests but only played the mini game enough to buy 2 sets of chests at the end of 2 towns and 1 set at the end of 1 town for 5 of the Feast and Fable selection kits - about 50 tasks each. As a bonus I got Summerhold to level 9 in all but one city without spending diamonds.

For that one city, 2 of my chest set buys gave me the level 1 Summerhold building instead of the upgrade. This left me 1 upgrade short for Summerhold. So I spent 500 diamonds to buy enough gems to open 3 extra chests and get the last upgrade for Summerhold.

I enjoy the event but only have enough time to really play the mini game in my main city.

 

[Just An Observer]

4 Sunhavens...3 LegLodges...18 Grills...3 Jesters...Smithy. This was a very "whale"-friendly event. More buildings are in inventory too with frag production on top of that. 854 was my final score, which was 185 above the Gold/Silver cutoff line in Cirgard.

 

[Orius Maximus]

I came out with a fully upgradable Sunhaven as well as the gold upgrade for the Heroes' Tavern, and a full Sunhaven on two other side cities. But I am definitely burned out from this one. This event used the sort of timed mechanics that are found in mobile/browser idle games which I absolutely hate. Now FoE has always had timers, but for a player who has an even moderately well built city, FoE will run on a daily schedule. I run my settlements on four hour schedules, and take the time to monitor guild business while doing so. This event format though requires checking in on a much more frequent basis, which is what I dislike about it the most. It's the kind of game where I think you're playing at least semi-AFK, but but I find it distracting and disrupting to my concentration on other tasks. I absolutely do NOT want to see more of these in the future. Once a year with St Patty's was already more than enough.

 

[Johnny B. Goode]

Final League numbers for the worlds where I have cities.
World: Gold, Silver
Arvahall: 666, 464
Brisgard: 672, 460
Cirgard: 669, 467
Dunarsund: 639, 455
East-Nagach: 709, 466
Fel Dranghyr: 689, 476
Greifental: 694, 465
Houndsmoor: 685, 467
Mount Killmore: 678, 458
Sinerania: 698, 470
Vingrid: 690, 464
Xyr: 656, 461
Yorkton: 701, 476
Angkor: 744, 465
Birka: 708, 465
Carthage: 666, 466

 

[xivarmy]

Adding to Johnny's data (edit and pericles addition below) the additional worlds where I have cities (and sorting them in order from highest to lowest gold cutoff:

World​	Gold​	Silver​
Dilmun​	790​	481​
Jaims​	770​	472​
Tuulech​	751​	484​
Angkor​	744​	465​
East-Nagach​	709​	466​
Birka​	708​	465​
Yorkton​	701​	476​
Sinerania​	698​	470​
Greifental​	694​	465​
Langendorn​	690​	467​
Vingrid​	690​	464​
Fel Dranghyr​	689​	476​
Houndsmoor​	685​	467​
Qunrir​	682​	464​
Mount Killmore​	678​	458​
Parkog​	674​	463​
Brisgard​	672​	460​
Odhrovar​	672​	470​
Cirgard​	669​	467​
Arvahall​	666​	464​
Carthage​	666​	466​
Xyr​	656​	461​
Noarsil​	653​	477​
Rugnir​	641​	463​
Dunarsund​	639​	455​
​	​	​
Min​	639​	455​
Max​	790​	484​
Median​	685​	466​
Average​	691​	467​

With a few worlds still missing, it seems Dunarsund wins the "most casual" award, while Dilmun, Jaims, Tuulech, and Angkor had the 1% put in a notably higher effort than your average server.

Jaims remains the most curious of these to me as it's a really-old world with a decent total population. I wonder if some of the top guilds there had internal competition over who was in gold or something

Silver seems pretty tight everywhere - less than 1 run in the difference between the easiest world and hardest.

 

[Pericles the Lion]

Tuulech finished at 751/484

 

[LoveNkind]

I got SOK "prizes." I remember when those were the BEST prizes in the game. Years ago. Now I throw them away, even the upgraded ones. Maybe there could be a shrink kit to turn them into 1 x 1s.
And this junk they made more FRAGMENTS. Forge of fragments is a lot less fun.

 

[honey55]

I like this event but think it lasts too long. It's my fault i suppose for going for gold league as a free to play player. Once i committed to one town a day i had to see it thru. I lost to much sleep over it. That said, since i managed to stay in gold, it was worth the effort. I did buy gemstones once with diamonds i earned in the game. I bought the largest pack, i think it was under 2000 diamonds. I planned on buying it at the beginning as i knew I'd need more gemstones to do one town a day. Between that and incidents, it was enough in my world.

 

[FluffyPhoenix]

Glad it's over. I hate Cookie Clicker: Forge edition.

 

[PJS299]

Glad it's over. I hate Cookie Clicker: Forge edition.

I loved cookie clicker... What a fun game. But yeah, FoE+Cookie Clicker isn't my favorite.

You can also hack Cookie Clicker, you name your bakery a certain name, and it gives you dev tools.

 

[Orius Maximus]

With a few worlds still missing, it seems Dunarsund wins the "most casual" award, while Dilmun, Jaims, Tuulech, and Angkor had the 1% put in a notably higher effort than your average server.

Jaims remains the most curious of these to me as it's a really-old world with a decent total population. I wonder if some of the top guilds there had internal competition over who was in gold or something

Silver seems pretty tight everywhere - less than 1 run in the difference between the easiest world and hardest.

No idea. Jaims is my main, and I didn't get anywhere near silver let alone gold. There is a bit of whale competition at the top though, particularly in the handful of guilds that do GvG. I got the Tavern upgrade and the full manor, and that's what mattered.

Tuulech was one of the two sides I completed, but I know little of the guild politics there.

The only reason I bothered working on this event in my side cities was because completing city tasks awarded Wishing Well and shrink kit fragments.

 

[Lorendar]

Ho hum, another pay to play and win event with more merge empire style playing. Seriously, change the name of the game to "Merge of Empires", already.

 

[Darkest.Knight]

The event was pretty easy, even my miners completed it w/o much effort.

 

[Flynn013]

Easy event, just time consuming. I got 2 Sunhavens and the Legendary Lodge upgrade with no diamonds or cash spent.