Emberguard
Well-Known Member
If I can only see 8 members at a time in the list. By the time I screenshot 10 different sections it'll already be too late to be of any use.
-
We are looking for you! Always wanted to join our Supporting Team? We are looking for enthusiastic moderators!
Take a look at our recruitement page for more information and how you can apply:
DeletedUser40197
Our guild is 60+ and have utilized this a few times. I know of other guilds of similar sizes and in particular a guild of 80 that have also done this and been able to achieve their goal... might not get your guy everytime, but if you don't try there is no chance at all, unless they admit it freely. Which does happen, as often I believe it is unintentional. (Misunderstanding, miscommunication)
BruteForceAttack
Well-Known Member
Screen shots
Screen shots only works if no hits are called. When multiple provinces are flagged for strategic reasons and hit is called on another province. Whilst most of guild members hit the correct province someone may hit a province that was not called for or start a new flag.
Screen shots only works if no hits are called. When multiple provinces are flagged for strategic reasons and hit is called on another province. Whilst most of guild members hit the correct province someone may hit a province that was not called for or start a new flag.
Attachments
Harbinger963
New Member
When you’re 5 days in, and bottom, no one is playing anyway. You see a handful taking positions and doing fights for personal fps, etc but as a guild, not a lot. The reason for the suggestion is there are too many NAPs and other collaborations taking place.
it’s ok if you think it’s a crap idea... was just throwing it for consideration. I know you’re playing...
Here is another (hopefully not so crap). Have “Finish Building” as a prize, so you don’t have to use diamonds. These can be used when chosen. Having a building that takes 6 hours forces diamonds to be used. Other options should be available.
DeletedUser40197
Yep, definitely not without its limits, for sure. And I think that's where the more competitive guilds tend to agree a log would be a nice feature.... As it currently is, we work with what we have at our disposal.
RazorbackPirate
Well-Known Member
While I'm sure that's the case, kicking a guild off the board then deprives the individual members of that guild the ability to attain personal rewards. If anything, it's the small fry player in the small fry guilds that need those rewards the most. If folks personally want to give up 5 days in and forgo their personal rewards that's fine, but to set up a system that boots players because their guild is in last place is wrong.
Also, there's nothing wrong with collaboration or alliances with other guilds. It's a viable strategy. No reason why folks should be deprived of creating them.
I would not be opposed to Inno creating this, but I would not ask Inno to create this. I play for free. Why would I ask the company that allows me to play for free to compromise their income earning potential in any way? This round, I've spent about 300 or so diamonds, yet they were all free. Sure I'd love to save them for other uses, but I earn them to spend them. They cost me nothing but time.
Joe the Unforgiving
New Member
I would like to suggest that the Goods required to erect GBG Buildings be more equal. The ratios of the required Goods is outrageous and it has become challenging to balance the Guild Treasury.
DeletedUser24719
This is a poorly thought out and executed feature at best but in INNOs rush to max income they are willing to give members substandard play. But the biggest problem with this feature is its just too darn long and boring as can be! And I don't see much change in the leagues at all. The top guilds will for the most part remain in the platinum league.
LarryBiggs
New Member
Guild Battlegrounds should be inter-world.
BruteForceAttack
Well-Known Member
At first it seems ok, but think about it Can Top guilds from "World of Angkor" compete against Top guilds of "World of Arvahall"?
Also what if one of the server is down for few mins/hrs whilst all other world servers are up.
DeletedUser40197
@Salsuero I would actually like to amend my use if the word tool in any prior post that was in response to your suggestion that inno would have provided us tools if they intended them to be used within GBG. Our tools are our phone or PC that allows us to access the game. The features found within the game are then what we utilize in order to play the game. So anything I referred to as a tool would be more accurately described as a feature to facilitate our game play (whether it's a message system, goods, league icons, etc.) All features that enable the player or guild to play how they wish andor enact a strategy.
DeletedUser40197
I'm curious to know why you think that?
Last edited by a moderator:
Salsuero
Well-Known Member
Well, choosing to have a maxed out guild comes with pros AND cons.
There's definitely a political joke there... but I'll abstain for the sake of forum peace! LOL
Salsuero
Well-Known Member
I said every guild is FIGHTING for 1st. If they aren't fighting (vis-a-vis they've given up before starting), they aren't what I'm talking about. I'm talking about all the guilds that want to actually win. If you just want to "participate" then you're not FIGHTING for anything.
No, I'm not. It's not a TOOL. It's the means by which we determine how to win. I defined TOOL in terms of what you are trying to claim by examples that are actual tools. Having a map is necessary to know how to play... it's not a means to create alliances. One could do so, but it has nothing to do with why they gave us a damn map and you know it.
What about the rest of the game where not every guild is Platinum? Brag much? One would think that the top-most guilds would mean you'd want to win, not just participate.
Good for you and your guild. I think it's a terrible idea for the game in general, including the rest of the guilds. This game isn't only about satisfying the Platinum guilds. There's GvG if you want more of that kind of guild dominance.
Correct... and not for alliances. Thanks for agreeing with me.
Being utilized, yes... being designed into the feature...... no.
Can we directly message A GUILD? No. We can message members. But not the guild. I get the feeling you're arguing for the sake of arguing now.
Don't know what that is. But if you want GvG, it still exists.
But if Inno wanted this to be "a feature" as you suggest, Inno would've actually made it "easy" and that's not what they've done. Remembering the name of a guild? Why rely on memory when you design a feature while you could simply make it visually available? Yeah... that's because it's not what they decided to do.
Uh huh.
Agent327
Well-Known Member
Goods are based on the era's your guildmembers are in. Ratios are actually balanced, so if it has become challanging to balance the Treassury, you are doing something wrong.
Emberguard
Well-Known Member
Actually you can on desktop but it can only be viewed on desktop (the guild forums allow you to copy a guild into a thread)
Emberguard
Well-Known Member
Actually not every guild is fighting for 1st. Some fight for 2nd or to overtake the guild closest in strength to them.
RazorbackPirate
Well-Known Member
That is true for a particular round, that is not true for GBG as a whole. Everyone is fighting to be the top dog in GBG. Only one will make it.
BruteForceAttack
Well-Known Member
Not really, some guilds don't care.
Emberguard
Well-Known Member
For a very small pool of players sure. Already nearing the end of Round 3 we've faced just about every top guild for our world and they've all decided it's between my guild and one other. Every other guild either doesn't have the resources to compete or doesn't have the co-ordination and motivation to care/ They all know it and have stated it. Everyone else is competing against the other guilds. They're not even competing for top 2 and I'm talking about an established world that's been around since early 2015