DeletedUser27889
What? I'm so confused no where in that post you quoted of me do I mentioned needing brass and I skimmed the thread you linked and I don't talk about brass there either?Still remember Manda the first and his needs for brass.
https://forum.us.forgeofempires.com...-alabaster-from-my-guild-leaders.21311/page-6
Brass is LMA and I'm Indy so when I'm talking about needing goods for negotiating GE, for myself I'm talking CA and Indy. Perhaps I missed something in what you quoted but I have no need for Brass and If I did I would just trade down my indy goods.
The goods you'll most need will be current and previous to negotiate GE. Tech and CMap can require 2-3 ages back if memory serves but don't quote me. Once you're beyond that point previous era goods are of no use to you. It's also very easy to get previous era goods by posting a trade unfavorable to yourself, say 1:5 or 1:1 your current: several eras back needed. Once you get to ME you will need to refine CA and on for each new era.
Old goods, such as brass, are completely worthless to a later era player. If you have a guildmate constantly taking your trades perhaps they assume you need it and are doing you favors? I always take the trades of my guildmates even when I don't need what they are offering because I want to help them. If someone believed they were making a profit off of me however, I would not be a happy camper.