I see the lively discussions on the forum have continued!
I would agree Inno has gone a little overboard on chasing the elusive whale. While I was not a whale, they lost what monetary income they were getting from myself and several others in my circle. Instead of supporting the F2P users in FoE, my nephew got a new sliding miter saw and portable table for his small workshop, and I am taking a few more fishing trips! The loss of income from players like myself leaves more and more income they have to make up in some way.
GbG was a good income producing start for Inno. The F2P users with those shiny new winner’s towers rode the coat tails of the P2P users who rushed all those buildings to make it happen. We all play the same game and know how much it costs to win now. It isn’t like any one Guild has a secret formula to win without spending a lot of diamonds to do it. Coming in second costs as much, or more and the same with third, they just do not get the full, shiny new building. If you do not rush buildings, you are hitting full attrition gain tiles. If you do not think it costs all that much to win a season, make yourself the personal building rusher for the guild and spend your diamonds to rush ALL the buildings ALL season. I can tell you it was very expensive when I was one of the several members rushing buildings!!! Now that I joined the F2P, it costs me nothing!
Back OT for the new raids addition!
I am withholding judgement, but as even the cheerleaders know deep down, Inno is not going to add content that is not going to have a Return On Investment. Put bluntly, they are not adding this new feature to reward those that are not supporting the game. They are adding this content to pull more income from players that are still monetarily supporting the game. If there is a group element to it, a few will pull the financial burden for the F2P, same as in GbG. If it goes anything like the event mechanics now, it will still cost everyone.
Speaking of costing everyone… The game has become very adept at pulling those free diamonds from even the stingiest of players. Everything is being developed now to the point users come up juuuuuust a tad shy of achieving goals. If you have been watching, you will have seen it. I get a chuckle each event when it appears, and it always appears anymore. Death of a thousand cuts, a penny here, a penny there. You listen, you can hear it in the posts too.