Why are you reading it in an angry or embarrassed or defensive manner? Go back and read all but the last line calmly. The last line was feed exactly for a response you gave just to show that no body can always add feeling to a text post.
Also, why not respond to every part of my post? What about:
This is a huge problem in my world. They are killing the server every season. More and more people are just quitting.
We are also in need of better responses of than the usual. "Join a better guild", "get more players", etc etc etc.
We have 80 players, we are currently in the top diamond island. We didnt get here by not being good. However the gap between the top 2 guilds and the rest of the guilds on the server is so extreme, it is no longer fun. It is worse for us to be stuck with them than it is to be in platinum where we could actually use our attrition every day. Here we are denied from even getting 1/5 of it spent, slowing us even further while they gain even more. They do not destroy camps when taking each others provinces adding even more misery to everyone stuck with them.
Now read that with description, not anger nor any other negative emotion.
As for my suggestion in not showing other guilds points on a province, this is not mine, nor the first. Remember, there is more than just this 'us' forum. There is one for every language. Examples: 'en', 'es', 'de'.... etc
There are so many ideas, and great ones at that, that INNO is ignoring.
Any suggestion that this is driving people away from the game is merely anecdotal. Unless you've got real numbers, like Inno does, you're best to stay away from that argument entirely. My anecdotal information shows that since the introduction of GBG, due to the time GBG requires, players have been shutting down multiple cities to focus on just one.
That's what I did. Prior to GBG, I had 2 cities, after GBG was introduced, I found it just too time consuming to maintain 2 cities, so I abandoned on of them. To other players on that world, it may appear that I've left the game, but I've not. I simply left that world.
In regards to the basis of your complaint, we fully understand the issue, with most commenting having been on both sided of the reward farming issue. I also agree it's a problem. Unchecked greed run rampant. To me, the only way to address the issue and return GBG back to it's original intent is to remove the Diamonds and FPs from the personal rewards and add them to the chests instead.
GBG would once again be about getting the highest spot in the league possible to get the highest chest rewards. It would no longer be about locking everyone else off the map in order to maximize rewards for yourself, by denying rewards to others. Any other suggestion to fix the issue won't fix the issue because it doesn't address the issue that causes the behavior.
Personal rewards also seems to be the issue few want to address. Without addressing the root, any of the many suggestions is a fail. You can't fix the issue by dancing around the cause of the issue.
So in the absence of addressing the root cause, personal rewards, where does that leave you? With the suggestions that have already been given you. Join a better guild, or get more or better players so you can join the dance.